Does the replacement RE take its claim subject to equities against the old RE? Primary RE Ltd v Great Southern Property Holdings Ltd & Ors [2011] VSC 242

  • Author : Samuel Hopper - 12-07-2011

In the Primary RE case, the new RE sought relief from forfeiture of leases terminated following breaches of the lease by the former RE.

The landlord argued that the former RE would have been estopped from seeking relief from forfeiture because it had failed to make an application for relief from forfeiture following service of s 146 notices coupled with the public announcement by the receivers of the land owning companies of their intention to sell the properties.

The Court held that the former RE would have been estopped from seeking relief from forfeiture.


Importantly, the Court also found that any right that may have transferred to Primary RE would also have been subject to the same estoppel.

The result seems to be that any claim that can be brought by the new RE under s 601FS is also subject to defences to those claims (or, at least, to equitable defences).

The relevant comments are made at [180],  [188] and [189] of the judgment.

About the Author

Samuel Hopper

Recent Posts

CTRS Regulations – 30 September 2021 is approaching fast …

Samuel Hopper Date: 23-09-2021

CTRS Regulations – My First Comments

Samuel Hopper Date: 24-08-2021

Wait times in the Building and Property list at VCAT

Samuel Hopper Date: 20-08-2021

CRTS extension has been gazetted and published

Samuel Hopper Date: 23-12-2020

First VCAT decision about the CTRS…

Samuel Hopper Date: 05-11-2020

Double win for the Tigers and a win for tenants in the Court of Appeal

Samuel Hopper Date: 19-10-2020