Jury is Out: Why Shifting to Judge-Alone Trials is a Flawed Approach to Criminal Justice

  • Author : Felicity Gerry QC - 06-05-2020

List member Felicity Gerry QC has published a new article via The Conversation.


"Last month, Victoria swiftly pushed through a bill introducing judge-only criminal trials as a short-term measure to tackle the absence of court sittings during the coronavirus lockdown.


The new law, which was cautiously welcomed by the state Criminal Bar Association, puts Victoria in line with other states that already have judge-only trials as a permanent option.


The ACT also passed an emergency bill last week approving judge-only trials temporarily.


In Victoria and other states, there is a requirement for the accused person to consent to such a trial. The new ACT law, however, allows a judge to order such a trial whether the accused agrees or not. This was not welcomed by the Law Council of Australia and is now the subject of a constitutional challenge."


Read the full article here

About the Author

Felicity Gerry QC

Recent Posts

Felicity Gerry QC leads a group of international lawyers and experts on women, peace and security in a submission to the UK Defence Committee Inquiry into the Withdrawal From Afghanistan.

Felicity Gerry QC Date: 20-10-2021

Women and International Peace and Security in Afghanistan

Felicity Gerry QC Date: 18-06-2021

OPCAT, places of detention and COVID-19

Felicity Gerry QC Date: 28-05-2020

Joint Criminal Enterprise in the Kosovo Specialist Chambers

Felicity Gerry QC Date: 19-05-2020

The impact of COVID-19 and Online Courts on Human Trafficking Victims who Commit Crime in Australia

Felicity Gerry QC Date: 12-05-2020

Jury is Out: Why Shifting to Judge-Alone Trials is a Flawed Approach to Criminal Justice

Felicity Gerry QC Date: 06-05-2020