Serious Injury Update - Noori v Topaz Fine Foods

  • Author : Oliver Lesage - 17-01-2019

Serious Injury Update - Para (c) & ‘disentangling’ in Noori v Topaz Fine Foods [2018] VSCA 323 (5 December 2018)

The case of Noori is an appeal in respect of a Serious Injury Application based on paragraph (c) of s134AB of the Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic) (“the Act”).

The worker fell from a stepladder and developed symptoms of acute and disabling pain.

There was no organic injury. Rather, his new pain symptoms constituted an aggravation or exacerbation of his prior psychiatric illness. The injury satisfied the ‘serious injury’ definition, but the trial judge rejected the application on the basis that he had difficulty disentangling work related symptoms from the totality of the worker’s condition.

The Court of Appeal held [at 5] that no question of ‘disentanglement’ arises under para (c) of the definition of serious injury. Disentanglement is a task which only arises in relation to para (a) of the definition. That is, where the application is based on the ‘permanent serious impairment or loss of a body function’ – in which case the Court is obliged by s 134AB(h) of the Act to exclude from consideration ‘the psychological or psychiatric consequences of a physical injury’. This involves the ‘disentangling’ of the psychological consequences from the physical consequences of the injury. Whereas,  paragraph (c) enables the Court to take into account both psychological and physical consequences of a physical/psychiatric injury.

The Court of Appeal held [at 33] that it was neither necessary nor appropriate to separate out or ‘disentangle’ the consequences of the applicant’s pre-existing psychiatric condition in circumstances where the accident ‘triggered’ his experience of pain. 

About the Author

Oliver Lesage

Recent Posts

Personal injury update. Damages.

Oliver Lesage Date: 24-10-2019

TAC update: Unidentified driver & notice requirements under s96(2) of the Transport Accident Act 1986 (Vic) 1986 judicially considered in Kirk v Transport Accident Commission [2019] VCC 1126 (26 July 2019)

Oliver Lesage Date: 06-08-2019

Serious Injury Update - Noori v Topaz Fine Foods

Oliver Lesage Date: 17-01-2019

Update - General Damages Awards

Oliver Lesage Date: 27-03-2018

What constitutes a business record? - Charan v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2018] VSC 3

Oliver Lesage Date: 29-01-2018

Pain and Suffering Update 2017 - Oliver Lesage Barrister

Oliver Lesage Date: 13-12-2017